Roberto De Zerbi must unleash statement summer signing to have any chance at Stamford Bridge

Photo: TVSEI / Wikimedia Commons / CC BY-SA 3.0
Tottenham Hotspur travel to Stamford Bridge on Saturday for a fixture that I think it’s fair to say few Lilywhites fans are relishing.
Historically, Spurs’ record against Chelsea is appaling. That record is even worse away from home. Spurs have won just 1 of their last 15 Premier League encounters with the Blues, drawing twice in that period. And to add another miserable statistic to the pile, the North Londoners have only ever beaten the West Londoners once at Stamford Bridge since the Premier League’s inauguration.
It would be an understatement to say Roberto De Zerbi has got a job on his hands to buck the trend.
If De Zerbi is to find a way through, the answer is already in his squad, and it cost £85m.
Mateus Fernandes arrived in the summer as the signing that reinforced Spurs’ ambition. Manchester United were in the race, but Tottenham won it, and the 22-year-old Portugal international has said De Zerbi’s personal pitch convinced him. His numbers at relegated West Ham were exceptional. He won 73 tackles and 214 duels last season, more than any of his team-mates, and only Jarrod Bowen created more chances than his 42. That’s a box-to-box, all-action midfielder in exactly the mould De Zerbi wants, and it’s the profile Spurs have lacked for years.
And yet he has struggled to hold down a regular place. He lasted 63 minutes against Everton, then was taken off at half-time against Aston Villa after De Zerbi said he didn’t like the performance. The problem has been less the player than the position. Fernandes has been pushed into a number 10 role he was never signed to play, and it’s hard to judge a midfielder fairly when he’s asked to do a job that isn’t his.
The case for the pivot
Fernandes belongs in a double pivot next to Sandro Tonali. Tonali provides the control and the passing range. Fernandes provides the legs, the pressing and the ability to carry the ball out of tight spaces. Together they would give Spurs both an anchor and an engine, which is what you need at Stamford Bridge. With a player like Fernandes alongside him, Tonali is freed to dictate play, and the team gets the aggression and the forward momentum that De Zerbi’s style depends on.
At the moment, Conor Gallagher is the man preferred alongside or in front of Tonali. Nobody questions his work rate, but he simply isn’t as good as Fernandes. Spurs need quality as well as industry if they’re going to hold the ball and escape Chelsea’s press, and Fernandes offers more of both.
Why this game demands it
Chelsea’s midfield is changing. Enzo Fernández, the man who inspired their 2-1 win over Spurs in May, has left for Manchester City. In his place, Xabi Alonso is leaning on Moisés Caicedo, back from a calf problem, and 36-year-old Jordan Henderson, who joined on a free transfer from Brentford.
Don’t be fooled by the age. Henderson scored twice and set up another on his home debut in a 5-1 win over Bournemouth two weeks ago, and the partnership has given Chelsea a far sturdier base after a shaky start to the season. Henderson made four tackles and seven recoveries that day, and Caicedo made four tackles of his own. This is a pair that wins the ball and uses it well, and Spurs will have to be at their best to live with it.
It’s also a pair Spurs can attack. Henderson is 36 and Caicedo is only just back from injury. A midfield of Tonali and Fernandes, with energy, athleticism and the ability to take the game to them, is how you test them.
The injury situation makes the choice easier, too. Rodrigo Bentancur is suspended. James Maddison and Dejan Kulusevski are doubts after long spells out, and even if they make the squad, neither can be relied on for 90 minutes. De Zerbi needs to get the foundations right, and the foundation is the midfield pivot.
The risk
Of course, there’s a case against. Fernandes is 22, he’s still adapting to a new club, and Spurs haven’t been prolific. Starting him in a high-stakes away fixture is a gamble.
But the alternative is also a gamble: keeping faith with a midfield that has already been found wanting. Gallagher has had his chances, and for many supporters he has proved he isn’t really good enough for a club with Spurs’ ambitions. De Zerbi, though, appears to have blind faith in him. Loyalty is a fine quality in a manager, but at some point it has to give way to evidence. When the fans can see the problem, and the manager can’t, the result is usually another afternoon of frustration. Stamford Bridge is not the place to find out again.
Handing Fernandes the job means accepting the risk that he’ll make mistakes. Persisting with Gallagher means accepting that the same flaws will show up again, and against a Chelsea side with this much quality, they’ll be punished.
The verdict
Spurs sit 16th and Chelsea are in the top five. Realistically, a point at Stamford Bridge would be a good result. To get it, De Zerbi has to be bold. Start Fernandes alongside Tonali, let him play where he’s strongest, and give the club’s second biggest summer investment the chance to show why Spurs paid so much for him.
If not now, then when?
Will Witts
Contributor to The Lilywhite Ledger
Related Articles

Spurs
Roberto De Zerbi and Luca Williams-Barnett scoop Premier League awards for October
Tottenham Hotspur collected two Premier League honours for October, with Roberto De Zerbi named Manager of the Month and academy graduate Luca Williams-Barnett winning Creative Moment of the Month.

Spurs
Tottenham lodge official complaint to Pro Ref with pundits and ex-referees split
Spurs want answers after Mathys Tel was forced off by a challenge that drew only a foul despite a lengthy VAR check, with ex-referees and pundits divided on whether it deserved a red card.

Spurs
Spurs' winning streak ended in hapless display at Elland Road
Tottenham Hotspur were beaten 1-0 by Leeds United at Elland Road in a game littered with controversy.